Showing posts with label Indiana Jones. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Indiana Jones. Show all posts

Wednesday, 18 March 2026

The Compromise Candidate (Hugo Cinema 1990)

This blog post is the thirty-third in a series examining past winners of the Best Dramatic Presentation Hugo Award. An introductory blog post is here.  

The 48th World Science Fiction Convention held in The Hague, Netherlands was the most international Worldcon to date. Fans arrived from 31 countries, flying in from five different continents. The United States still represented the largest number of attendees (1,618 fans from the USA), but as far as we can tell this was the first time that they were not an outright majority at the convention.
The Adventures of Baron Munchausen cost 
almost $50 million to make and earned
only eight million. It's chaotic, and far from 
Terry Gilliam's best work.
(Image via Variety)


There had been a sense in 1990 that the world had changed, and that science fiction was undergoing a dramatic shift in popularity. As August approached, registrants began to wonder whether they would be joined by fans from the former Soviet Union, since the Berlin Wall had fallen and more people would have the freedom to travel within Europe. In the end there were at least 21 fans at the convention from former Soviet republics.

Fans from the Anglosphere greeted the prospect of a more international Worldcon with optimism and positivity. In the lead up to the convention, Forrest J. Ackerman noted that, “this is truly an international gathering,” adding that he hoped to hear people in the hallways speaking Japanese, Russian, Finnish, and Hungarian. New York-based conrunner Neil Belsky, who had helped bring the con to the Netherlands, proclaimed that the convention’s attendees proved that the genre was transcending borders of language or culture. For example, there were discussions at the business meeting about creating a Hugo category for translated works. It’s worth noting that these reactions were markedly different from the xenophobia that had greeted the 1970 Worldcon in Germany, which had prompted a xenophobic backlash that had briefly excluded all non-English-language works from the Hugos.

With this evident uptick in interest from outside the United States, there was speculation that the Hugo ballot might see more works by international authors. But as per usual, category after category was dominated by American authors and fans, and just as predictably there was nobody from the winning movie on-hand to accept the award for best dramatic presentation.

Best Dramatic Presentation offered a smorgasbord of big-budget American Hollywood fare. The two highest-grossing movies of the year, Batman and Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade had earned nods. Academy Award Best Picture nominee Field of Dreams was on the ballot, as was James Cameron’s underwater alien movie, The Abyss. Rounding out the list was box office disaster, The Adventures of Baron Munchausen.

It’s a mostly credible shortlist, with few real omissions. We might argue that Bill and Ted’s Excellent Adventure has had a greater cultural impact than a t least one movie on the shortlist. And writing in Critical Wave, Brian Aldiss complained that Hungarian filmmaker Ildikó Enyedi’s comedy-drama My 20th Century deserved consideration, “especially after it won the Cannes Film Festival award.” Back To The Future 2, The Little Mermaid, and The Navigator all narrowly missed the shortlist. Critically ridiculed, The Final Frontier became the only Star Trek movie featuring the original cast not to earn a Hugo nod.

Terry Gilliam's filmmaking shows clear inspiration
from the work of previous Hugo-finalist Karel Zeman.
(Image via IMDB.)
Overall, we felt like the shortlist provides a fair representation of the year’s science fiction and fantasy cinema. And for perhaps only the second meeting of our cinema club, most members remember seeing many of these films in a theatre. The one movie that many of us felt was not worthy of nomination was Terry Gilliam’s The Adventures of Baron Munchausen. The long-winded movie introduces audiences to an aging fabulist who entertains children by recounting unbelievable exploits such as journeys to the Moon, getting swallowed by a sea monster, and being dragged across war-torn Europe with eccentric companions. Although the movie has moments that work, Gilliam’s self-indulgent flaws as a filmmaker are magnified by the chaos of the plot. Kim Newman of the fanzine Vector dismissed The Adventures of Baron Munchausen as an inconsistent and frustrating movie, and made an apt observation that the work owed an enormous debt to Czech filmmaker Karel Zeman. The gender representation is dreadful, as every woman in the movie is either a goddess, a temptress, or someone to be rescued. One can see the seeds of Gilliam’s more recent political statements in his earlier work.

Almost equally chaotic and stylized — but far more successful — was Tim Burton’s Batman. The highest-grossing movie of the year brought the comic book character to the big screen for the first time in almost 30 years. It succeeded largely on the charisma of its stars, a superb soundtrack, the exuberant production design, and on general vibes. But the plot — involving poisoned beauty products and some kind of city held hostage — is meandering and slightly confusing. However, this didn’t prevent the movie from hitting the cultural zeitgeist at the right moment, and its presence in both fandom and among the broader public was inescapable.

The only old-school science fiction movie on the shortlist this year may have been James Cameron’s The Abyss. Following the crew of an underwater mining operation who encounter alien life in the deepest parts of the ocean, it pits jingoistic militarism against American labourers and scientists. Some themes of the movie have aged well, but the gender politics surrounding the blue-collar protagonist Virgil (Ed Harris) and his ex-wife oceanographer Lindsey (Mary Elizabeth Mastrantonio) are regressive at best. The fact that director James Cameron was in the middle of a divorce while making the movie is fairly evident. Contemporaneous reviews of the movie are unforgiving. David Ansen in Newsweek panned James Cameron’s underwater adventure: “The Abyss is pretty damn silly — a portentous deux ex machina that leaves too many questions unanswered and evokes too many other films.”

Field of Dreams may be the most Baby Boomer-coded
movie ever made, weaving in dozens of signposts
to historical events of particular significance to
those born in the USA between 1945 and 1960, including
a book banning scene in an elementary school.
It’s like someone tried to adapt Billy Joel’s
We Didn’t Start The Fire into a feature-length movie.
(Image via Film89.co.uk)
Based on a novel by Edmontonian W.P. Kinsella, Field of Dreams is an unusual inclusion on the Hugo Award shortlist — and one that was not without controversy. Following a farmer Ray Kinsella (Kevin Costner) who is guided by unseen voices that tell him to build a baseball diamond in his corn field, it’s a saccharine road trip through mystical Americana culminating in the resurrection of famous baseball players. At times, the corniness isn’t contained to the farming. Some contemporaneous fans seemed to think that it was “bereft of internal consistency, not science fiction, not a Hugo movie,” while others argued that the magical realism of the story made it award worthy. In his review, SFF author John Varley wrote, “Who is the voice? Shit, I dunno. I don’t care. There are so many possible interpretations of the impossible events, and the movie makes no attempt to favor any of them.” For all this, the movie remains intensely likeable and charming, though many of our cinema-watching group agreed that it did not belong on the Hugo ballot.

The final movie on the shortlist was the capstone of the Indiana Jones franchise: The Last Crusade. In this third outing for the swashbuckler, Indiana Jones (Harrison Ford) teams up with his father Dr. Henry Jones (Sean Connery, best-known for starring in Zardoz) in a quest to retrieve the cup that Jesus Christ drank from at the last supper. What elevates the movie is a combination of chemistry between the two leads, a nice plot twist featuring love interest Elsa Schneider (Alison Doody), and a solid emotional core. Upon revisiting it, many of us felt that the movie has held up better than any other in the Indiana Jones saga; surpassing even the original. “To say that Indiana Jones and the Last Crusade may be the best film ever made for 12 year olds is not a backhanded compliment … more cerebral than the first two Indiana Jones films and less schmaltzy than the second, this literate adventure should make big bucks by entertaining and enlightening kids and adults,” Variety raved.

Interestingly, the 1990 Hugo Award race demonstrated the importance of ranked ballot voting, as Field of Dreams was well in the lead on the first ballot; receiving 110 first-preference votes to only 83 for Indiana Jones. But Field of Dreams was the second-preference movie for very few voters; picking up only one vote on the second ballot, and another 13 on the second ballot. Last Crusade, however, was a second choice for almost everyone, and earned the award as the compromise candidate; the movie that everyone liked, and few people rejected out of hand.

As the decade came to a close, the Hugos recognized probably the best science fiction or fantasy movie of the year, while offering a fairly reasonable short list that represented the preoccupations of fandom. It was overall a good year.

Friday, 11 October 2024

Hugo Cinema Goes Mainstream (Hugo Cinema 1982)

This blog post is the twenty fifth in a series examining past winners of the Best Dramatic Presentation Hugo Award. An introductory blog post is here.

Science fiction cinema of the 1980s holds a special place in the hearts of many fans … perhaps because so many of them fell in love with the genre during a decade in which the genre entered the mainstream.
Kurt Russell as Snake Plissken in Escape From
New York
. The movie somehow didn't earn
a Hugo Award nomination.
(Image via IMDB)


During that decade, Hollywood studios watched the stratospheric box office revenue being generated by movies such as Halloween, Alien, and of course Star Wars … and wanted to get in on the action. Suddenly, studios were willing to finance up-and-coming talent, and took the chance to take swings at genre, hoping to strike gold.

This influx of new SFF cinema allowed bold ideas to be rewarded at the box office, and in time get the critical praise that it was missing at the time of release.

The Hugos of 1982 marked an inflection point in the evolution of cinema. The previous year, the Hugos celebrated the likes of Ray Bradbury, Ursula K. Le Guin, old serials like Flash Gordon, and the hard science fiction of Carl Sagan. Now, a new guard was taking centre stage, as fresh new ideas shook up the industry.

There’s also a shift in the coverage that these films would receive in contemporaneous fanzines. While discussions of science fiction movies were once relegated to the occasional dismissive rant on the letters page, many fanzines now engaged seriously with cinema. In particular, Jim Harris’ Science Fiction Review regularly provided pages of reviews.

This sea change was most evident in some of the movies that did not end up on the ballot. Our cinema club had universal praise for John Carpenter’s Escape from New York.. Like a lot of Carpenter’s work, it’s a masterclass in effective use of resources; star Kurt Russel served as costume director, while Carpenter himself wrote the score. Protagonist Snake Plissken may not be the first antihero in genre cinema, but he is among the most memorable.

Another film that does a lot with a little is the low-budget Canadian film Scanners. A hidden psychic war is a neat premise that’s elevated by how director David Cronenberg leaned into the body horror. While it wasn’t to everyone’s taste the animated film “Heavy Metal” also did something unique by showing an adult vision of science fiction using a medium primarily shown to children (something Japan had been doing for years).

There was Clash of the Titans which showed that there was still life left in the Ray Harryhausen extravaganza and Superman 2 was a blockbuster that was denied a nomination for technical reasons.
Clash of the Titans may have been the last great
stop-motion epic.
(Image via IMDB)

There was even more to be impressed with from our cousins in the horror genre. Sam Raimi got his start with Evil Dead, the psychological horror drama Possession with Sam Neill and the Academy Award-winning special effect powerhouse An American Werewolf in London. The film club felt that any of these movies would be worthy of nomination and yet none of them were.

What was nominated was a little more mainstream.

While a lot of the group had fond memories of watching Terry Gilliam’s Time Bandits as children, even its most ardent fans admitted that the script was a little bit more “shaggy” than they had remembered. While it had some charm, the movie played out like a series of disconnected skits flowing awkwardly from time period to time period. The group felt that maybe the script could be a little tighter, and some of us loathed it. 

The movie Outland was somewhat the opposite of Time Bandits. Dream logic and whimsy were replaced with the grunge of a mining town (in space!), with black-and-white morality. It was essentially “High Noon in space” … but that turns out to be a fairly good setup for a movie. A lone sheriff standing up for what’s right for the whole when everyone else is only looking out for themselves. Whether it is 1952 or 2024 that premise will always work with a certain audience and many in the club felt that it worked well here. Sean Connery puts in a remarkably restrained performance that ranks among his all-time best roles, as Marshall William O’Niel. Set on Jupiter’s moon of Io, Outland critiques corporate exploitation of workers in a mining colony. What makes this movie shine are the details: O’Niel’s family turmoil seems like a natural reflection of his dedication to his job. Marion Lazarus (played by Frances Sternhagen) provides an interesting ally to the protagonist. At least one member of our cinema watching group thought this deserved to win.
Sean Connery (left) and Frances Sternhagen
anchor the movie Outland with restrained
performances and a gritty charisma.
(Image via IMDB)


In between these films lies Excalibur, an example of muscular filmmaking at its worst. Retelling the archetypal western fantasy King Arthur through a grim-and-gritty lens, it is essentially a movie about men covered in metal swinging swords, trying to get unobtainable women, and making poor decisions that doom everyone around them. This might have been an interesting movie if it had anything new to say about the legend of Arthur, but sadly it does not. The group was somewhat lukewarm on this film. It is fairly well made and looks great and is replete with British/Irish acting legends but is an enormous let-down after John Boorman’s previous movie.

Conversely, we were surprisingly impressed with Dragonslayer, a Disney live-action sword and sorcery directed by Matthew Robbins. Most of us had never seen it, and the consensus was that it was a lot more enjoyable than it had any right to be. This mix of a sorcerer’s apprentice tale with a quest to defeat evil may not have been fresh or bold, but was the right kind of “likeable” for some members of the group. The dragon effect (made by ILM in their first work for another studio) was surprisingly effective for the era. As Richard E. Geiss wrote in Science Fiction Review: “Who would have thought the Disney studios would ever create such a realistic, honest, quality sword and sorcery film as this?”

This brings us to the gravity-crushing neutron star in the room Raiders of the Lost Ark. Hugo-winners George Lucas and Steven Spielberg teamed up to launch one of the biggest movie trillogies of the 1980s, remixing classic adventure serials of the 1930s to create something fantastic. Much of the movie has aged well -- Harrison Ford is at the height of his magnetic charisma, Spielberg’s visual storytelling prowess makes the action comprehensible and engaging, and cinematographer Douglas Slocombe’s beautiful lighting makes every frame a piece of art. However -- at the risk of being castigated for nerd heresy -- there were some aspects of the movie that simply didn’t hold up. Despite being introduced early in the movie as Indiana Jones’ equal, romantic lead Marion Ravenwood (Karen Allen) ends up being kidnapped repeatedly and spends much of the movie haplessly calling for help. The narrative structure may have intentionally aped that of a 1920s cinema serial, but several of those episodic sections simply fell flat (in particular the chase through Cairo). Despite these quibbles, most of our cinema club felt that it was still the best choice to take home the Hugo that year.

Going forward this decade will be remembered as the one where science fiction cinema finally became accepted as mainstream, not to mention cool and profitable. Even today, Hollywood leans on a SFF-adventure template as their tentpole for big releases, planning their annual schedule around their leases. Directors’ visions from this decade will shape cinema for generations to come. From where we sit, it looks like there is no going back.