Organized
labour in science fiction LIST AS SORTABLE EXCEL DOCUMENT Additional
suggestions are welcome. This list is
to supplement our blog posts on labour in SF: part one, part two, part three Terminology: “Business union” is defined as an
organization that is legally certified by the government to negotiate on
behalf of a group of workers. “Solidarity union” is defined as a
group of workers organizing themselves on a grassroots basis to seek
concessions from an employer. “Guild union” is defined as a group
of workers whose labour negotiating ability stems from their near-monopoly on
a particular set of skills. (Note: This
list excludes inherently criminal organizations such as the Assassin's Guild
from Discworld, the Guild of Thieves from Robert Silberberg and Randall
Garrett's A Little Intelligence or the Traitor's Guild from James
Blish's A Style in Treason.) |
||||
Year |
Title
/ Author |
Union
Model |
Qualitative
Depiction |
Extent
of depiction |
1890 |
News From Nowhere –
William Morris |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction –
worker organizing leads to utopia |
Secondary |
1897 |
Log of the Flying Fish – Harry Collingwood |
Solidarity union –
(shipbuilding) |
Negative depiction –
character complains at length about how unions impede production. |
Tertiary |
1899 |
The Sleeper Awakes – H.G. Wells |
Business union – (aeronauts) |
Mixed depiction – Unions
have made great gains for workers in the future, but have become an
institutional power that can be misused by union leadership. |
Secondary |
1908 |
The Iron Heel – Jack
London |
Business union (Various) |
Negative depiction –
unions end up siding with fascism. |
Secondary |
1913 |
Engineer Menni –Alexander
Bogdanov |
Business unions in a
workers’ state (engineering and mining) |
Positive depiction –
Union activism and industrial action act as catalysts of the revolutionary
change in Martian society. |
Secondary |
1914 |
The Five Years Of Silence
– A.C. Michael |
Business unions
(manufacturing, resource extraction, construction) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights major battles for basic labour rights. |
Primary |
1914 |
The Dream of Debs – Jack
London |
Business union (General) |
Negative depiction –
organized labour depicted as ruinous and tyrannical |
Primary |
1923 |
Nordenholt’s Million – J.J. Connington |
Solidarity
union |
Mixed depiction – unions
raise some objection to techno-fascism, but are crushed. |
Tertiary |
1925 |
Alice’s Egg Plant –
Walter Elias Disney |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Union is depicted as irrational. Workers are easily fooled into scab labour. |
Primary |
1929 |
The Defeat of Jonathan Govers - Volodymyr Vladko |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Union is on strike for legitimate grievances. |
Primary |
1937 |
The
Company or the Weather – Miles J. Breuer |
Business union (Farmers) |
Neutral depiction – Union
just exists and works for members. |
Secondary |
1938 |
The Toys Go On Strike –
Enid Byton |
Solidarity union (Toys) |
Positive depiction –
Union stands up to mistreatment of workers. |
Primary |
1940 |
Robbie - Isaac Asimov [Short Story] |
Business union |
Negative depiction -
Antagonistic to progress. |
Secondary |
1940 |
The Roads Must Roll -
Robert A. Heinlein [Short Story] |
Business union
(Transportation) |
Mixed - Union gained some
big objectives in the past, but Some union members are conned into destroying
the roads |
Primary |
1941 |
A Gnome There Was – Henry Kuttner |
Solidarity union (mining) |
Positive depiction –
Union organizer shows gnomes that monarchy exploits them. |
Primary |
1942 |
Breakdown – Jack
Williamson |
Business union (Engineers
and spacemen) |
Negative depiction –
Union power is stifling and overreaching |
Primary |
1946 |
Decadence – Romain Gary |
Business union (General) |
Negative depiction –
Union leader is a sadist and a serial killer. |
Primary |
1946 |
Slaves of the Lamp – Leo
Zagat |
Business union
(Psychoneers union) |
Negative depiction |
Secondary |
1949 |
The Green Forest – A.E.
Van Vogt |
Business union
(Spacement’s Union) |
Negative depiction |
Secondary |
1950 |
The Masters of Sleep – L.
Ron Hubbard [Novel] |
Business union (Friends
of Russia Communist International Objectors Social Hall Lumberjacks Local
No.261) |
Negative depiction –
union is working to advance the agenda of a foreign nation |
Secondary |
1951 |
The Man In The White Suit
- Ealing Studios [Movie] |
Business union |
Negative depiction -
Antagonistic to progress. |
Primary |
1951 |
The Traders (Foundation)
- Isaac Asimov [Short Story] |
Guild union |
Negative depiction -
Nepotistic and anti-intellectual. |
Secondary |
1951 |
Day Of The Moron - H.
Beam Piper [Short Story] |
Business union |
Negative depiction - Protects
unqualified workers. Bureaucratic and obstructionist. |
Primary |
1952 |
Another Kind – Anthony
West |
Business union (Railways
and Various) |
Mixed depiction – Unions
call a general strike over legitimate grievances, but this leads to civil
war. |
Secondary |
1952 |
The Space Merchants -
Frederick Pohl & Cyril Kornbluth [Novel] |
Business union
(Agricultural) |
Negative depiction -
Labour union exploits worker. |
Secondary |
1952 |
The Demolished Man -
Alfred Bester [Novel] |
Business union |
Negative depiction -
Corrupt union leadership. |
Tertiary |
1952 |
Robots of the World!
Arise! |
Solidarity union |
Negative depiction –
Robotic workers strike unreasonably. |
Primary |
1953 |
Cue for Quiet – T.L.
Sherred |
Business union (repair) |
Positive depiction –
Protagonist is concerned with the plight of unions |
Tertiary |
1953 |
The Troublemakers – Poul
Anderson |
Guild Union |
Negative depiction – part
of an autocratic system to keep workers in line |
Secondary |
1953 |
Null ABC – H. Beam Piper |
Solidarity union
(Reading) |
Mixed depiction – Works
to protect rights of skilled workers, but may be unnecessary. |
Secondary |
1953 |
The
Syndic – Cyril Kornbluth |
Business union (General) |
Mixed depiction – One
union is equivalent to organized crime. Other helps revitalize America. |
Secondary |
1953 |
Starman
Jones – Robert A. Heinlein [Novel] |
Guild union (Transportation) |
Negative depiction –
Union is anti-meritocratic. |
Secondary |
1954 |
Disqualified – Charles L.
Fontenay |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Existence of union means workers are “paid too much” |
Tertiary |
1954 |
Backlash – Winston Marks |
Business Unions
(Multiple, implied that they are trades and arts unions) |
Mixed depiction – union
leadership is hypocritical, on one hand fighting against indentured
servitude, but then using it themselves |
Secondary |
1954 |
An Earth Gone Mad – Roger Dee |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Union cares only about the power of cubes. |
Secondary |
1955 |
The Cartels Jungle –
Irving E. Cox |
Business union (General –
All workers forced to join “Union of Free Workers.”) |
Negative depiction –
Union depicted as corrupt and authoritarian. |
Primary |
1955 |
One-Shot – James Blish |
Business union |
Negative description –
Described as corrupt. |
Tertiary |
1955 |
Full Cycle - Clifford D.
Simak |
Business union (General
industrial) |
Mixed depiction –
Criticizes current state of labour, but suggests it might evolve into
something better. |
Primary |
1955 |
Nine Men In Time – Noel
Loomis |
Business union (Printers) |
Mixed depiction |
Secondary |
1955 |
Meeting of the Board – Alan E. Nourse |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Overly powerful unions act irrationally towards management prompting a
crisis. |
Primary |
1956 |
Dying To Live - E. C.
Tubb |
Business unions – Actors,
and manufacturing |
Mixed depiction – Union
has protected workers from pain, and increased employment through
scope-of-work arguments, but also can be callous towards individual workers. |
Primary |
1956 |
Worlds Without End –
Clifford Simak |
Business union (general
labour) |
Negative depiction –
Union does not represent best interests of workers. |
Primary |
1957 |
Do It Yourself – Milton
Lesser |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction –
Union is banned, but union organizer protagonist helps workers anyhow. |
Primary |
1957 |
Edge of the Knife – H.
Beam Piper |
Business union (academic) |
Mixed depiction – union
protects employee, but employee might not deserve protection |
Teritary |
1957 |
Strikebreaker - Isaac
Asimov [Short Story] |
Solidarity union (Waste
processing) |
Negative depiction -
Strike threatens survival of colony. |
Primary |
1957 |
The Lineman – Walter
Miller Jr. [Short Story] |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Union described as “yellow-bellied obscenity.” |
Tertiary |
1959 |
Guardian Devil – Robert
Silverberg |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Union leader corrupt and deliberately causes race riots. |
Tertiary |
1959 |
Hunter Patrol – H. Beam
Piper |
Business union |
Mixed depiction –
Conversation between unionist and capitalist |
Secondary |
1960 |
Stress Pattern – Robert
Silverberg |
Business union
(unspecified) |
Positive depiction –
Union protects jobs and helps people fulfill potential. |
Primary |
1960 |
Matchmaker – Charles L.
Fontenay |
Business union
(“psycho-artists”) |
Negative depiction –
Union expulsion is used to coerce protagonist |
Secondary |
1960 |
Divvy Up – Milton Lesser |
Business union (bus
drivers and medical workers) |
Negative depiction –
Unions are corrupt and without ethics |
Secondary |
1960 |
A Few Miles – Phillip
Jose Farmer |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Union causes headaches. |
Tertiary |
1960 |
The Apprentice - James
White [Short Story] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Employee has job protection |
Secondary |
1962 |
Last Year’s Grave Undug – Chan Davis |
Business unions
(multiple) |
Mixed depiction – Union
is implied to have helped reduce inequality. But also corrupt former union
president is brutal leader in post-apocalyptic. |
Secondary |
1963 |
Stand By – Philip K. Dick |
Business Union (civil
servants) |
Negative
depiction – Union is
corrupt and entrenched. |
Secondary |
1963 |
Omicron - Ugo Gregoretti |
Business union |
Positive
depiction – Alien organises labour collective. |
Primary |
1964 |
Martian Time-Slip –
Philip K. Dick [Novel] |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Corrupt union leadership. |
Secondary |
1964 |
No Vinism Like Chauvinism
– John Jakes |
Business union
(Entertainment and War, which are the same in this future) |
Mixed depiction |
Secondary |
1964 |
Sacheverell – Avram
Davidson |
Business union |
Positive depiction |
Tertiary |
1965 |
Calling Dr. Clockwork –
Ron Goulart |
Business Union – (“Food
Scenters”) |
Positive depiction –
Union ensures that protagonist maintains employment during illness. |
Secondary |
1965 |
Subspace Explorers – E.E.
“Doc” Smith |
Business union |
Negative depiction
- union is antagonist. Book promotes "Enlightened
Self-Interest" which is at odds with collective action. |
Secondary |
1966 |
A Relic Of Empire – Larry
Niven [Short Story] |
General statement about
unions. |
Positive depiction –
Described as ‘necessary.’ |
Tertiary |
1967 |
The Rival Rigelians –
Mack Reynolds |
Solidarity union vs.
employer-dominated union |
Positive depiction –
workers find solidarity in struggle for real worker representation |
Secondary |
1968 |
The Day of the Coastwatch
– Philip McCutchen |
Business union – Various |
Negative depiction –
Labour movement is depicted as decadent and in-league with authoritarian
government. |
Secondary |
1969 |
The Freak – PG Wyal |
Solidarity union
(beggars) |
Positive depiction –
striking workers seek equitable wages |
Primary |
1970 |
Alien Island – T.L.
Sherred |
Business Union
(Machinists) |
Positive
depiction – protagonist is unionized worker |
Tertiary |
1971 |
Holdholtzer’s Box – David R. Bunch |
Business union
(manufacturing) |
Positive
depiction – Employer praises union shop because “happy workers make better
workers.” |
Tertiary |
1972 |
Seventy Years of Decpop –
Philip Jose Farmer |
Business union (Canners) |
Negative
depiction - union
members vote against their own interests |
Tertiary |
1972 |
Merchant of Venus –
Frederik Pohl |
Business union (mining) |
Negative
depiction – Union collects excess fees |
Tertiary |
1972 |
Clone – Richard Cowper |
Business unions (multiple) |
Negative
depiction – Government uses union violence to reduce population. |
Secondary |
1973 |
Deaf Listener - Rachel
Cosgrove Payes |
Guild union (telepaths) |
Positive depiction –
Union works to prevent genocide |
Secondary |
1974 |
The Monster of Peladon –
Dr. Who |
Business union (Resource
extraction) |
Mixed depiction – Workers
have valid concerns, but are pawns in larger political game. |
Secondary |
1975 |
Survivors – Terry Nation |
Business union |
Mixed depiction – In a
post-apocalyptic setting a labour union leader tries to take over the world.
But still stands for worker solidarity. |
Secondary |
1977 |
Wobblies From Space –
Leslie Fish |
Business union |
Negative depiction
- Union rules make it impossible for starship to run efficiently. |
Primary |
1978 |
Hitchhiker’s Guide To The
Galaxy - Douglas Adams [Radio/Novel/Television] |
Guild Union |
Negative depiction –
Antagonistic towards progress, interested primarily in “gravy train.” |
Tertiary |
1978 |
1985 – Anthony Burgess |
Business Union (General) |
Negative depiction –
Unions depicted as oppressive and anti-freedom. |
Primary |
1979 |
The Kilohertz War – Alien
Worlds [Radio] |
Business Union (Technicians) |
Negative depiction –
complaints about union striking. |
Tertiary |
1981 |
The Revolution from
Rosinante – Alexis A. Gilliland |
Business Union
(Construction) |
Negative depiction –
Union officials are obstreperous and intransigent. |
Secondary |
1981 |
Highliner – C.J. Cherryh |
Business Union |
Positive depiction –
Union fights to protect worker safety |
Primary |
1983 |
We, The People – Jack C.
Haldeman |
Business Union
(Janitorial) |
Positive depiction –
Union has won benefits for its members |
Primary |
1986 |
Watchmen – Alan Moore [Comic book] |
Business Union (Police) |
Mixed depiction – 1973
police strike causes violence, but may be justified. |
Tertiary |
1987 |
The Time Guardian - Brian
Hannant |
Business Union |
Negative depiction – Evil
Cyborg Trade Unionists try to destroy the last vestiges of humanity. |
Secondary |
1987 |
Robocop - Paul Verhoeven [Movie] |
Business Union (Police) |
Negative depiction -
Heroic characters cross picket line. Quote: "Police officers don't
strike." |
Primary |
1988 |
Desolation Road – Ian
McDonald |
Solidarity Union – (Steel
workers) |
Positive depiction- Union
forms in response to company killing protesters. |
Secondary |
1988 |
The Long Orbit – Mick
Farren |
Business Union |
Positive Depiction –
Union is key to fighting inequality |
Secondary |
1988 |
They Live – John
Carpenter [Movie] |
Business Union
(Construction) |
Mixed depiction – Union
is “closed shop” but hires itinerant protagonist anyway. |
Tertiary |
1989 |
Orbital Decay - Allen
Steele [Stories / Novel] |
Business Union
(Construction) |
Positive depiction -
Union helps ensure safer workplace. |
Primary |
1990 |
The Difference Engine –
William Gibson and Bruce Sterling |
Business Union (Mining) |
Mixed depiction – Union
involved with assassination. But also helps build a better world. |
Tertiary |
1991 |
SEAQ and Destroy –
Charles Stross |
Business Union |
Mixed depiction – Union
calls for general strike in opposition to Soviet Union. But hasty action
contributes to global catastrophe. |
Tertiary |
1992 |
Heavy Time - CJ Cherryh [Novel] |
Business union (Mining) |
Negative depiction -
employer-dominated union. |
Primary |
1992 |
We Are Not Amused – Laura
Resnick |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Helped advance rights of women |
Primary |
1992 |
Men At Arms – Terry
Pratchett |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Protects marginalized workers from exploitation. |
Secondary |
1994 |
By Any Means Necessary -
Babylon 5 [Television] |
Business union |
Mixed depiction -
Striking workers are violent, but achieve fairer wages. |
Primary |
1996 |
Night Sky Mine - Melissa
Scott [Novel] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Ensures equitable wages. |
Secondary |
1996 |
Bar Association - Deep Space Nine [Television] |
Solidarity union |
Mixed depiction -
Achieves fairer wages, but must be disbanded because it’s “no longer needed.” |
Primary |
1998 |
[Webcomic] |
Business union
(Technicians) |
Positive depiction –
Union membership brings wage benefits to worker. |
Tertiary |
1999 |
Against The Tide Of Years
– S.M. Stirling [Novel] |
Business union
(Dockworkers) |
Positive depiction –
Protagonist provides help to union trying to support fair wages. |
Tertiary |
2000 |
1632 - Eric Flint [Novel / Series] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Organizing prosperous economy. |
Secondary |
2000 |
Candle - John Barnes [Novel] |
Guild union |
Positive depiction -
Union provides health, dental and legal coverage. |
Secondary |
2000 |
Company Man – Robert
Jackson Bennett [Novel] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
Union works to combat inequality. |
Secondary |
2000 |
Cosmonaut Keep – Ken
MacLeod [Novel] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
Balances power of capital. |
Secondary |
2000 |
Midnight Robber – Nalo
Hopkinson [Novel] |
Solidarity union
(Transporation / pedicab drivers) |
Positive depiction –
fights for fair compensation |
Secondary |
2000 |
SimGen Sequence (AKA “Sims”) – F. Paul Wilson |
Solidarity
union (manual labour) |
Positive
depiction – fights for the rights of non-human sentients. |
Primary |
2000 |
Perdido Street Station –
China Mieville [Novel] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Unions provide counterbalance to strength of capital. |
Secondary |
2000 |
Click, Clack, Moo -
Doreen Cronin |
Solidarity union (Cows) |
Positive depiction
- Union negotiates fair agreement between cows and farmer in which
working conditions are improved (blankets provided to cows so they aren't as
cold). |
Primary |
2001 |
Bendless
Love – Futurama [TV Episode] |
Business union
(Manufacturing) |
Negative depiction –
protagonist is a scab worker. Union is mob-connected and corrupt. |
Primary |
2004 |
Star Trek Enterprise –
“Storm Front” |
Business Union
(Construction) |
Negative Depiction –
Gangsters are tied to the labour movement |
Tertiary |
2004 |
Iron Council – China
Mieville |
Business union (Railway workers) |
Positive depiction |
Primary |
2005 |
Old Man’s War – John
Scalzi [Novel] |
Business union |
Negative depiction –
Striking workers on the news portrayed as violent. |
Tertiary |
2006 |
Small Minded Giants -
Oisín McGann |
Business union |
Positive depiction |
Secondary |
2007 |
Business union (video
game players) |
Positive depiction –
protects workers from unfair employer abuses |
Primary |
|
2007 |
Safehold – David Weber |
Business union |
Positive depiction |
Tertiary |
2007 |
Dirty Hands - Battlestar Galactica [Television] |
Solidarity union |
Negative depiction -
Heroic governor bargains in bad faith by holding gun to the head of a
worker. |
Primary |
2009 |
The Wind-Up Girl - Paolo
Bacigalupi [Novel] |
Guild Union |
Negative depiction -
antagonism towards entrepreneur protagonist. |
Secondary |
2010 |
For The Win - Cory
Doctorow [Novel] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
ensuring workers’ rights. |
Primary |
2010 |
Damage Time - Colin
Harvey [Novel] |
Guild Union |
Negative depiction -
Union excludes vulnerable population. |
Secondary |
2010 |
Kraken - China
Miéville |
Guild Union |
Positive depiction |
Secondary |
2010 |
The Great Bay – Dale
Pendell [Novel] |
Business Union
(Electrical workers) |
Mixed depiction |
Tertiary |
2011 |
The Expanse Caliban’s War (2012) Nemesis Games (2015) Babylon’s Ashes (2016) Persepolis Rising (2017) Tiamat’s Wrath (2019) Leviathan Falls (2021) |
Multiple Business Unions |
Positive depiction –
Union integral in democratic governance. Help defend rights of oppressed
workers. Provide legal counsel to workers in need. |
Secondary |
2011 |
Contagion [Movie] |
Business Union |
Negative depiction -
Union rules prevent adequate health care for major character. |
Secondary |
2012 |
High Stakes – Naomi Kritzer |
Solidarity Union (IWW) |
Positive depiction –
Union helps fight debt slavery. |
Primary |
2012 |
Existence - David Brin [Novel] |
Business Union |
Positive depiction -
Union is part of positive and functional workplace. |
Tertiary |
2012 |
“The Doctor Is Sin” –
Episode of Venture Brothers [Television] |
Business Unions (Machine
Workers, Nuclear Engineering and Custodial Super Science Unions) |
Mixed depiction – Union
has legitimate grievances but are treated as joke. |
Secondary |
2013 |
Phosphorus – Veronica
Schanoes [Short Story] |
Solidarity Union &
Business Union (Manufacturing, General Labourers) |
Positive depiction –
Union stands in opposition to unsafe work practices |
Primary |
2013 |
Burning Girls – Veronica
Schanoes [Novella] |
Solidarity Union (Garment
Workers) |
Positive depiction –
Union stands in opposition to unsafe work practices. |
Secondary |
2013 |
Fortune’s Pawn - Rachel
Bach [Novel] |
Business Union |
Positive depiction -
Union provides information to employees. |
Tertiary |
2013 |
The Day The Crayons Quit
– Drew Daywalt & Oliver Jeffers |
Solidarity Union |
Positive depiction –
Union helps improve the working conditions of labourers. |
Primary |
2014 |
Climbing the Date Palm –
Shira Glassman [Short Story] |
Business Union |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against wage theft. |
Primary |
2014 |
Ancillary Sword – Ann
Leckie [Novel] |
Solidarity Union |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against indentured servitude in tea production operation. |
Tertiary |
2014 |
War & Mir Vol. 2:
Darkold – Minister Faust [Novel] |
|
Positive depiction |
Secondary |
2014 |
The Goblin Emperor –
Katherine Addison |
Guild Union (Clockmakers)
and Business Union (Municipal Employees) |
Positive depiction –
Guild proposes improvement to infrastructure. |
Tertiary |
2015 |
Gentleman Jole and the
Red Queen – Lois McMaster Bujold |
Business Union (Sex Workers) |
Positive depiction –
Union is created to combat exploitation of vulnerable workers. |
Tertiary |
2015 |
C.O.W.L - Kyle Higgins
& Alec Siegel |
Business union
(Superheroes – “Chicago Organized Workers League”) |
Mixed depiction – Union
is scandal-ridden but well-intentioned. |
Primary |
2015 |
Windswept - Adam Rakunas [Novel] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
ensuring fair wages. |
Primary |
2015 |
Bangarang – Killjoys |
Business union |
Mixed depiction – Union
interferes with protagonists, but also helps vulnerable workers. |
Tertiary |
2015 |
All The Childhood You Can
Afford - Daniel Suarez [Short Story] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Ensures gains of automation are shared more equitably. |
Secondary |
2016 |
Checkerboard
Planet – Eleanor Arnason |
Business union (Natural
resource extraction) |
Positive depiction –
Labour organizer protagonist striving for better working conditions. |
Primary |
2016 |
[Novel] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Ensures workers’ safety and rights. |
Secondary |
2017 |
Little Witch Academia –
S02E01 “Samhain Magic Festival” |
Business union
(Janitorial services) |
Negative depiction –
Workers are pawns in the schemes of an evil capitalist. |
Primary |
2017 |
New York 2140 – Kim Stanley Robinson |
Multiple unions |
Positive depiction –
through co-ordinated action striking workers help reform democracy |
Secondary |
2017 |
Another Girl, Another
Planet - Lou Antonelli [Novel] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Ensures safety standards in construction. |
Secondary |
2017 |
Hunger Makes the Wolf / Blood Binds The Pack - Alex Wells [Novel/Series] |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Unionization drive is response to corporate exploitation. |
Primary |
2017 |
The Death and Life of
Schneider Wrack - Nate Crowley |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against exploitation of labour |
Primary |
2017 |
Quirks – Marie Vibbert [Short Story] |
Business union |
Mixed depiction – Union
uses memory uploads to share skills. |
Primary |
2018 |
Driving Ambition – Fiona
Moore [Novel] |
Business union (Self-driving cars) |
Positive depiction –
Union helps protect the rights of artificially intelligent workers. |
Primary |
2018 |
Sorry To Bother You - Boots Riley [Movie] |
Business union |
Positive depiction -
Balances power of capital. |
Primary |
2018 |
Unfulfilled/Bike Parade - South Park [Television] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
Union fights for safety standards and fair pay. |
Primary |
2019 |
Disco Elysium |
Business union
(dockworkers) |
Negative depiction –
Union is depicted as corrupt and involved in the drug trade. Union is
compared to “crime syndicate.” |
Primary |
2019 |
The Town Meeting –
Stephen Cox |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Union leader speaks up for persecuted citizens |
Primary |
2019 |
The Future Of Another Timeline - Annalee Newitz [Novel] |
Multiple unions |
Positive depiction –
Unions are depicted as allies in the struggle for women’s rights.
|
Secondary |
2019 |
Closed Shop – Kevin
J. Phyland [Short Story] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
Union fights for fair wages and public good. |
Primary |
2020 |
Upload - S01E07 "Bring
Your Dad To Work Day" |
Business union
(technology workers) |
Positive depiction –
Solution for workplace grievance. |
Tertiary |
2020 |
Hench – Natalie Zina
Walschots |
Business union (henchmen) |
Mixed depiction |
Tertiary |
2020 |
[Movie] |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction -
Organizing in adverse conditions. |
Primary |
2020 |
The Factory Witches of Lowell – C.S. Malerich [Novella] |
Business union (mill
workers) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights for better working conditions. |
Primary |
2020 |
The Salvage Crew – Yudhanjaya Wijeratne [Novella] |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Union secures better pay. |
Tertiary |
2020 |
The Fork – A. Parise |
Solidarity union
(Workers’ Collective) |
Positive depiction –
Union protects citizenry |
Primary |
2020 |
The Ministry for the
Future – Kim Stanley Robinson |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Heroic protagonist is a former union lawyer who embodies the values of the
labour movement. |
Tertiary |
2020 |
Hardspace:
Shipbreaker –Blackbird Interactive And expansion pack |
Business union |
Positive depiction –
Union protects vulnerable workers. |
Primary |
2021 |
All Rights Reserved -
Xauri'EL Zwaan |
Solidarity union –
(uploaded consciousnesses) |
Positive depiction –
Union resists indentured servitude |
Primary |
2021 |
The Hallowed Sky – Ken
MacLeod |
Business union – (General
labour) |
Positive depiction –
unions help take mankind to space |
Secondary |
2021 |
Committee on the Bounty – Keith W. Dickinson [Short Story] |
Business union –
spaceship crewmembers |
Negative depiction –
union’s officiousness causes destruction of ship. |
Primary |
2021 |
Machinehood – S.B. Divya [Novel] |
Business union
(construction) |
Mixed depiction – Union
funds antagonistic/violent protesters. Union also helps push back against
erosion of human rights. |
Secondary |
2021 |
Heritage - Superman &
Lois [Television] |
Business union
(manufacturing) |
Positive depiction –
Fights for worker wages and safety at villain Morgan Edge’s factory. |
Tertiary |
2021 |
Orumai’s Choice – Gautam Bhatia |
Solidarity union |
Positive depiction –
Sentient robots assert their right to work-life balance. |
Primary |
2021 |
The Horizon – Gautam
Bhatia |
Business union
(Agricultural workers) |
Positive depiction –
union is central to revolution seeking to address inequity and inequality in
society. |
Primary |
2021 |
Song of Slag – Louis Evans |
Solidarity union (Foundry
workers) |
Positive depiction –
union fights for fair compensation. |
Primary |
2021 |
The Association of Twelve Thousand Flowers - Ursula Whitcher |
Solidarity union (Jade
miners) |
Positive depiction –
Union counterbalances power of capital. |
Primary |
2021 |
The Revolution Will Not Be Served With Fries – Meg Elison |
Solidarity union (Fast
food workers and robots) |
Positive depiction –
Cross-species solidarity deals with severe workplace inequity. |
Primary |
2021 |
Z is for Zombies – TV
series Evil (episode written by Patricia Ione Lloyd) |
Business union (Warehouse
workers) |
Positive depiction –
Union provides voice for exploited workers (though formerly pro-union worker
elevated to management becomes exploiter) |
Primary |
2021 |
C is for Cop – TV series
Evil (episode written by Aurin Squire) |
Business union (Police) |
Negative depiction –
Police union acts to intimidate witnesses to shooting. |
Primary |
2022 |
Unionized
In The Butt And Now Everyone Is Safer, Happier And Better Paid – Chuck Tingle |
Business union (Spaghetti
Mug Manufacturing) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights for health and safety of workers as well as reasonable break
times. |
Primary |
2022 |
Ogres – Adrian Tchaikovsky |
Solidarity union
(Manufacturing) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against exploitation and racism. |
Secondary |
2022 |
We Built This City – Marie Vibbert |
Solidarity union (window
washing) |
Positive depiction –
Fight for safer work environment |
Primary |
2022 |
Day Shift |
Business union
(Supernatural pest control) |
Negative depiction –
Union is officious and bureaucratic. |
Primary |
2022 |
Babel: Or the Necessity
of Violence: An Arcane History of the Oxford Translators’ Revolution – R.F.
Kuang |
Guild union –
(Translators) |
Positive depiction –
Important tool in promoting class solidarity. |
Primary |
2022 |
Witch Hunt – Louise
Hughes |
Guild union – (wise women
/ witches) |
Positive depiction |
Primary |
2022 |
Tune in Tomorrow – Randee
Dawn |
Solidarity union –
Entertainment |
Positive depiction –
Union helps free magical beings from slavery |
Primary |
2022 |
When the Angels Left The
Old Country - Sacha Lamb |
Business union – Garment
workers |
Positive depiction –
Union helps immigrants find better life. |
Secondary |
2022 |
Star Trek: Picard
“Watcher” |
Business Union –
Information Workers |
Negative depiction –
Brynner information Systems trying to prevent an organizing drive. |
Tertiary |
2022 |
No Return –
Wide End |
Guild Unions (multiple)
and Solidarity Unions |
Mixed depiction – Some
unions are employer dominated (exploit workers, prevent competition). Others
are vehicles for emancipation. |
Secondary |
2022 |
Kid Wolf and Kraken Boy –
Sam J. Miller |
Business Union (Boxing) |
Positive depiction –
Helps improve lives of working people. |
Primary |
2022 |
City of Lost Chances –
Adrian Tchaikovsky |
Solidarity Union
(Manufacturing) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against exploitation |
Secondary |
2023 |
Lockwood & Co S01E04 |
Business Union |
Positive depiction –
Exploited workers urged to form union |
Tertiary |
2023 |
The Keeper’s Six – Kate
Elliott |
Solidarity Union |
Positive depiction –
Protagonist is a union organizer |
Primary |
2023 |
Last Act of the
Revolution – Louise Hughes |
Business union (factory
workers) |
Positive depiction –
Union helps free people from forced labour. |
Secondary |
2023 |
Alloy Cooperative – K.J.
Noakes |
Business union
(blacksmithing) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights against nepotism and ensures fair distribution of wealth. |
Primary |
2023 |
Not pounded By The
Physical Manifestation of My Own Screenwriting Because I’m On Strike And I
Deserve To Be Compensated For My Labor While Studio CEOs Take Record Salaries
– Chuck Tingle |
Business union
(screenwriters) |
Positive depiction –
Union fights for fair contract |
Primary |
2023 |
Station Six – S.J.
Klapecki |
Business Union |
Positive depiction –
Union fights to keep workers employed. |
Primary |
2023 |
One Man’s Treasure –
Sarah Pinkser |
Solidarity Union (Magical
waste collection) |
Positive depiction –
Union helps protect workers from unsafe waste. |
Primary |
2023 |
A Market of Dreams and
Destiny – Trip Galey |
Solidarity union
(factory workers) |
Positive depiction –
union works to liberate children from exploitative labour practices |
Primary |
2023 |
Starter Villain – John
Scalzi |
Soldiarity union
(dolphins) |
Positive-to-Mixed
depiction - Union leadership and members depicted as antagonistic and
obstreperous. But their grievances have merit. Boss gets to be the 'Hero.' |
Secondary |
2023 |
The Job At The End Of The World – Ray Nayler |
Business union (first
responders) |
Positive – Passing
reference to the union getting fair wages and health benefits. |
Tertiary |
2023 |
For All Mankind S04E01
“Glasnost” |
Business union
(construction workers on Mars) |
Negative – Passing
reference to a strike disrupting Mars operations. |
Tertiary |
2023 |
Julia – Sandra Newman |
Business union
(Agricultural and Manufacturing) |
Negative – Unions
complicit in the establishment of abusive totalitarian dictatorship. |
Tertiary |
2023 |
Any Percent – Andrew Dana Hudson [Short Story] |
Business union
(Warehouse) |
Positive – Unions provide
solution to increasing inequality and abuse of workers. |
Primary |
2023 |
Liberty’s Daughter –
Naomi Kritzer |
Solidarity union |
Positive – Unions provide
solution to increasing inequality and abuse of workers. |
Primary |
2023 |
Warped State – Jo Miles |
Solidarity union
(Several, but chemical workers prominent) |
Positive – Unions provide
the only counterbalance to an evil corporation. |
Primary |
2024 |
Floating Hotel – Grace
Curtis |
Business union – Butchers |
Negative – striking
workers cause problems for protagonist |
Tertiary |
2024 |
Warped State – Jo Miles |
Solidarity union – Chemical
Workers |
Positive - Unions provide
only counterbalance to evil corporation |
Primary |
2024 |
Club Contago - Eliane
Boey |
Business union – Port
workers union. |
Positive – Fighting
gamification of work and worker replacement by automation. |
Secondary |
2024 |
The Sentence – Gautam
Bhatia |
Solidarity union – mining
(anarchist union that also includes other professions) |
Positive – Union provides
counterbalance to upper-class side of city |
Secondary |
2024 |
Business union - Professional
magic practitioners (witches) |
Positive - Union opposes
exploitative labour practices, and encourages professional behaviour among
its membership |
Primary |
|
2024 |
Megalopolis – Francis Ford
Coppola |
Business union –
construction |
Negative – Offhand remarks
about union getting in the way. |
Tertiary |
I remembered one mention, towards the beginning of "The Kilohertz War," which starts ~24 minutes into part 4 of this War of the Worlds marathon special. Definitely negative, grousing about the technicians' union striking again.
ReplyDeletehttp://clearingthestatic.blogspot.com/2016/10/special-war-of-worlds-marathon-radio.html
That's a great find! Thank you! I will add this!
DeletePerdido Street Station: There's a typo in the title. Also, the description seems odd to me: "Mixed depiction - Crushing of strike provides background for story." Mixed how? Because the workers don't ultimately prevail? I mean... if that's your standard, then the actual non-fictional history of the world is also a negative depiction of labor, because these struggles do not always prevail, and virtually never do when the government is willing to use violence on behalf of management. Miéville is entirely on the workers' side, and he makes a point of showing that the strike is very effective - that's why the government is so afraid of it.
ReplyDelete(The only other "mixed" aspect I can think of is that there's a brief mention of a different union refusing to support the strike, possibly for racial reasons. But again, that is how things sometimes happen in the world, and Miéville does not depict it as an insurmountable obstacle; many of those people do eventually come around.)
Thank you for the feedback. I will edit the list accordingly in the morning.
DeleteAnother one is the Doctor Who story "The Monster of Peladon", which is set on a planet rich in important mineral where the guys who mine the mineral go on strike looking for better wages and conditions. When first broadcast (in 1974) it would have had interesting resonances for the British audience, as the country's coal miners had effectively brought down the government with a strike at the beginning of the year. I have not seen this story myself; from the synopsis the portrayal of the miners union sounds ambiguous but broadly favorable.
ReplyDeletehttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Monster_of_Peladon
Oh! That is a fantastic suggestion, Ian!
DeleteThank you. I will re-watch that episode, and get it into the list later this week.
If you're looking for examples from the world of children's fantasy, there is an intriguing short piece by Enid Blyton called "The Toys Go On Strike", in which a group of children's toys are so irked by their treatment that they go on strike. The strike is favourably depicted - the children have been behaving badly and the toys achieve their aims by striking (admittedly they do not form a union as such). What is funny about it though is that Blyton finds it hard to hide her raging conservatism - even though the logic of the story tacks one way, she still has to throw her reactionary views into the story. So when one of the toys is suggesting to the others that they go on strike, he says "It's not a very honourable course of action but I think we have no choice".
ReplyDeleteThe book "1985" by Anthony Burgess is half essay about "1984" and other dystopias (or as Burgess calls them "cacotopias"), but the other half is a novella where the main gist is that unions are terrible, and basically are just Uppity Workers trying to get, say, lunch-breaks-during-lunch-breaks and whatnot. (Not an actual example, but similarly ridiculous demands.)
ReplyDeleteAh! Thank you! That's a great addition to the list!
DeleteAlan E. Nourse, "Meeting of the Board" (1955): Future in which unions rule over management until one VP fights back (mixed depiction? - union leadership corrupt, but workers OK if naive). Text available on Project Gutenberg (https://www.gutenberg.org/files/22867/22867-h/22867-h.htm)
ReplyDeleteOh. Good find. Just read it, and have to say that I'd count that as negative. The union is depicted as being so irrational and destructive!
DeleteWhen the Angels Left the Old Country by Sacha Lamb features garment workers organizing & is a positive depiction!
ReplyDeleteThanks so much for including "Club Contango"! The union depicted is a port workers union, fighting gamification of work and replacement with virtual AI replicants.
ReplyDelete